Wagner vs Griswold: Choosing the Best Cast Iron Skillet.

Wagner and griswold are two popular brands of cast iron cookware with similar features, but wagner is known for its durability while griswold is preferred for its smooth cooking surface. Cast iron cookware has been a staple in kitchens for generations due to its durability, even heating, and versatility.

Wagner and griswold are two of the most recognized brands in the cast iron world, and comparing the two can be difficult. Both brands were manufactured in the united states during the same time period, and both are known for producing high-quality cookware.

However, there are distinct differences between wagner and griswold that set them apart. In this article, we’ll take a closer look at the history of both brands, the features that make them unique, and how they compare in terms of cooking performance. Whether you’re a collector or a home cook looking for a new piece of cookware, understanding the differences between wagner and griswold can help you make an informed decision.

Wagner vs Griswold: Choosing the Best Cast Iron Skillet.

Credit: www.ebay.com

Wagner Cast Iron Cookware

Overview Of Wagner Brand

Wagner is one of the oldest and most well-regarded cast iron cookware brands in the united states. It was started in 1891 in sidney, ohio and produced a wide variety of household goods, including cookware, for over 100 years. Wagner cast iron cookware is renowned for its superior quality, durability and design.

Wagner Vs Griswold: How Wagner Differs From Griswold In Terms Of Design And Production

Wagner and griswold were two of the most popular cast iron cookware brands in the united states during the late 1800s and early 1900s. Both companies were based in ohio, and their cast iron cookware became a staple in american kitchens.

However, there are some key differences between the two brands in terms of design and production.

  • Wagner’s cast iron cookware was designed to be more utilitarian than griswold’s. Wagner used thicker walls and a rougher, pebbled texture on the cooking surface, which made it more durable and less prone to sticking. Griswold, on the other hand, was known for its smooth surfaces and fine details, which made it more expensive but also more delicate.
  • Wagner also employed a mix of automated and hand-crafted production techniques, whereas griswold relied entirely on hand-crafted methods. This meant that wagner’s cast iron cookware could be produced more quickly and at a lower cost, but it also meant that some of the finer details of the cookware were lost.

Popular Wagner Cast Iron Cookware Products

Wagner produced a wide variety of cast iron cookware over the years, but some of its most popular items include:

  • Wagner ware sidney -o- series: These were some of the earliest cast iron cookware produced by wagner and included skillets, griddles, and dutch ovens. They are recognizable by the large -o- on the bottom of each piece.
  • Wagner sidney hollow ware series: This was a line of deep skillets and chicken fryers that were designed to be versatile and efficient for cooking a wide variety of dishes.
  • Wagner magnalite series: This line of aluminum cookware was produced by wagner in the 1930s and was known for its lightweight, non-stick surface.

Pros And Cons Of Wagner Cast Iron Cookware

Wagner cast iron cookware has many advantages, including its durability, versatility, and even heating. However, there are also some drawbacks to using this type of cookware.


  • Wagner cast iron cookware is incredibly durable and can last for generations.
  • The cast iron heats evenly and retains heat well, making it ideal for cooking a wide variety of dishes.
  • Cast iron is also naturally non-stick if it is seasoned properly, which means that it requires less oil for cooking than other types of cookware.
  • Wagner’s cast iron cookware is also relatively inexpensive compared to other brands.


  • Cast iron cookware is heavy, which can make it difficult to handle for some people.
  • It requires a bit of maintenance to keep it in good condition, including regular seasoning and cleaning.
  • Cast iron cookware can also be prone to rust and staining if not properly cared for.

Overall, wagner cast iron cookware is an excellent choice for anyone who loves to cook and is looking for durable, reliable cookware that will last for years to come. With its superior quality, classic design, and affordable price point, it’s no wonder that wagner has been a favorite of cooks around the world for over 100 years.

Griswold Cast Iron Cookware

Overview Of Griswold Brand

Griswold cast iron cookware was established in 1865. It is a well-known american company that produced high-quality cast-iron cookware for over a century. The popularity of griswold cookware grew rapidly due to its exceptional durability, perfect heating abilities, and distinctive designs.

The griswold brand closed its doors in the 1950s, but its products are still popular among collectors.

Wagner Vs Griswold: How Griswold Differs From Wagner In Terms Of Design And Production

Wagner and griswold are commonly compared since they are two well-known american cast iron cookware companies.

  • Griswold designed and produced cookware that was lighter and more precise when compared to wagner’s cast iron cookware.
  • Griswold focused on providing cast iron cookware with perfectly smooth surfaces, while wagner added distinguishing marks and patterns on their products.
  • Wagner’s cookware was gradually thickened over the years, while griswold’s cookware walls remained thin to reduce the weight and enhance heating quality.

Popular Griswold Cast Iron Cookware Products

Even though griswold closed its doors, you can still find its cast iron cookware products in antique stores and online shops.

  • Griswold #8 cast iron skillet: This skillet is recognized as one of the best in the business. It is smooth, lightweight and has a polished interior that provides optimal heat distribution.
  • Griswold #3 cast iron skillet: Good things come in small packages. The #3 skillet is ideal for single-serving dishes or small amounts of food.
  • Griswold #14 cast iron skillet: Conversely, the #14 skillet is perfect for large dishes, big batches of food, and serious kitchen work.
  • Griswold waffle iron: One of griswold’s signature products. The waffle iron’s intricate design and perfect heating abilities are unmatched.

Pros And Cons Of Griswold Cast Iron Cookware


  • Griswold cookware is made with precision and durability in mind. The construction process and quality of materials used ensure that griswold cookware will last for generations.
  • Griswold’s polished cooking surfaces allow for perfect heating and even distribution of heat throughout the cooking surface. This feature sets griswold apart from other cast iron cookware brands.
  • The griswold brand itself has a rich history, and many collectors prize it. Griswold cookware products are valued for their rarity, design, and functionality.


  • Since the griswold brand is no longer in business, their cast iron cookware products can be difficult to find, and when available, pricey.
  • Griswold used thinner walls in producing their cookware, which can result in quicker cooking times and heating differently from thicker walled pans. This feature can take time for cooks to adjust to.
  • Although the quality is high, griswold’s cookware is not immune to the usual cast iron cookware cons – it can be heavy, take some time for seasoning and can sometimes be challenging to clean.

The griswold brand is one of the most popular and well-regarded cast iron cookware companies in american history. They produced high-quality products with exceptional durability and perfect precision, which have made them highly sought after collector’s items. Despite some minor cons, griswold cast iron cookware is worthy of any kitchen.

Wagner Vs Griswold: Comparison And Contrast

When it comes to high-quality cast iron cookware, wagner and griswold are two of the most reputable brands. Each brand has its unique features, benefits, and drawbacks. This article will explore the key similarities and differences between wagner and griswold cookware to help you decide which one is better suited for your cooking needs.

Design And Production Quality

Both wagner and griswold are renowned for their superior design and production quality.

  • Wagner cookware has a smoother and more polished surface, whereas griswold has a rougher texture.
  • Wagner pans have a wider and flatter cooking surface, while griswold pans have a deeper and narrower cooking surface.
  • Wagner cookware is thinner and lighter, whereas griswold cookware is heavier and more substantial.
  • Wagner cookware has a thinner lip around the edge of the pan, making it easier to pour liquids without spilling.

Weight And Durability

The weight and durability of cast iron cookware are essential factors that affect its cooking performance and lifespan.

  • Griswold cookware is considerably heavier than wagner cookware, making it more durable and resistant to warping.
  • Wagner cookware may warp or crack over time due to its thinner and lighter construction.
  • Both wagner and griswold cookware require regular maintenance to prevent rust and preserve their seasoning.

Cooking Performance

The cooking performance of cast iron cookware is perhaps the most crucial factor.

  • Wagner cookware heats up faster and performs better for tasks that require high heat.
  • Griswold cookware takes longer to heat up but retains heat longer and distributes it more evenly.
  • Wagner cookware is ideal for searing and grilling meats, while griswold cookware is better suited for soups and stews.

Price Comparison

Pricing is always an essential consideration when making a purchase decision.

  • Wagner cookware is generally considered a bit more affordable than griswold cookware.
  • Wagner cookware pieces can range from $20 to $200, depending on the item and the condition.
  • Griswold cookware can range from $50 to $500, depending on the item and the condition.

Which Brand Is Better?

Both wagner and griswold cookware have their loyal fans, and both brands have many positive attributes to offer. However, which brand is better for you depends on your individual needs and preferences.

  • If you’re looking for lighter and more affordable cookware that heats up quickly and works great for searing and grilling meats, wagner cookware might be the way to go.
  • If you prefer heavier and more durable cookware that retains heat efficiently and works well for soups and stews, griswold cookware might be a better choice.

Overall, choosing between wagner and griswold cookware comes down to personal preference and cooking style. Consider your cooking needs, budget, and preferences to decide which brand is the better option for you.

Care And Maintenance Of Cast Iron Cookware

Wagner Vs Griswold: Care And Maintenance Of Cast Iron Cookware

Cast iron cookware, with its superior heat retention and durability, has become a staple in many kitchens. Two of the best-known brands of cast iron cookware are wagner and griswold. While both brands are highly valued, caring and maintaining them correctly can make a significant difference in their longevity.

This blog post will focus on the importance of proper care and maintenance to keep your wagner and griswold cast iron cookware in excellent condition for years to come.

Importance Of Proper Care And Maintenance

Proper care and maintenance are essential to ensure that your wagner and griswold cast iron cookware lasts a lifetime.

  • Avoid using metal utensils as they can scratch the surface of the cookware.
  • Never soak your cast iron cookware in water to avoid rusting.
  • Avoid using dish soap when cleaning your cast iron cookware as it can remove the seasoning.
  • Ensure that your cookware is completely dry before storing it.

Cleaning Techniques

Proper cleaning is crucial to maintain the integrity of your cast iron cookware.

  • After each use, wash your cast iron cookware with warm water and a stiff brush.
  • If there are any stubborn food particles, you can use kosher salt to scrub the surface gently.
  • Once clean, wipe the cookware dry with a clean towel.
  • Never put your cast iron cookware in the dishwasher.

Seasoning Techniques

Seasoning your cast iron cookware is essential to keep it in top condition.

  • Preheat your oven to 375 degrees fahrenheit.
  • Apply a thin layer of vegetable oil to the surface of the cookware, making sure to cover all sides.
  • Place the cookware upside down on the middle rack of the oven.
  • Bake for one hour, then turn off the oven and let the cookware cool down.

Storage Tips

Proper storage is crucial to prevent your cast iron cookware from rusting and tearing.

  • Store your cast iron cookware in a clean, dry place.
  • Never stack your cast iron cookware as it can cause scratches and damage.
  • If storing your cookware for an extended period, apply a thin layer of vegetable oil to the surface.

By following these tips for care and maintenance of cast iron cookware, you can ensure that your wagner and griswold cast iron cookware will last for years to come. Embrace the charm and durability that cast iron cookware brings to your kitchen and take care of it properly to enjoy your cooking experience.

Frequently Asked Questions Of Wagner Vs Griswold

What Is The Difference Between Wagner And Griswold Cast Iron Skillets?

Wagner and griswold cast iron skillets are both highly sought after by collectors for their quality, durability, and craftsmanship. While the two brands are similar in some ways, there are a few key differences that set them apart. Wagner is known for its lightweight design and smooth surface, while griswold is known for its heavy weight and rough surface.

Which Is Better: Wagner Or Griswold Cast Iron Skillets?

Both wagner and griswold cast iron skillets are excellent choices for cooking enthusiasts and collectors alike. The choice between the two largely comes down to personal preference and the particular features you are looking for in a skillet. Some people prefer the lightweight, smooth surface of a wagner skillet, while others prefer the heavy weight and rough surface of a griswold skillet.

How Can You Tell If A Cast Iron Skillet Is A Wagner Or Griswold?

One way to tell if a cast iron skillet is a wagner or griswold is to look for the manufacturer’s stamp on the bottom. Wagner skillets are usually marked with the words “wagner” or “wagner ware” and a size number, while griswold skillets are typically marked with the words “erie” or “griswold” and a size number.

Another way to distinguish between the two is to examine the skillet’s surface and weight.

What Are The Benefits Of Cooking With Cast Iron Skillets?

There are many benefits to cooking with cast iron skillets. Cast iron heats evenly and retains heat well, which makes it ideal for cooking a wide range of dishes. Cast iron skillets are also naturally non-stick when properly seasoned, which means you can cook with less oil and butter.

In addition, cooking with cast iron can increase the amount of iron in your diet.

How Do You Care For A Wagner Or Griswold Cast Iron Skillet?

To care for a wagner or griswold cast iron skillet, it is important to season the skillet regularly with a thin layer of oil. This helps to create a natural non-stick surface and prevent rust. After use, the skillet should be cleaned with a stiff brush and hot water, and then dried thoroughly with a clean towel.

Store the skillet in a dry place to prevent rust.


After comparing wagner and griswold brands, it can be concluded that both these brands have earned their reputation for producing high-quality cookware. While wagner is preferred for its durability and sturdiness, griswold is known to produce finely crafted and aesthetically pleasing cookware.

The choice between the two brands ultimately comes down to individual preferences and requirements. That being said, it is important to take good care of your cookware to maintain its longevity, even if you opt for the best brand out there.

Keeping it clean, drying it properly, and using it correctly will help your cookware last for generations. As a final note, while the debate over which brand is superior may continue, both wagner and griswold remain popular choices for all kinds of cooking enthusiasts.

Leave a Comment